Companion planting benefits for commercial growers and backyard gardeners
My grandmother always had cut flowers in vases around her home. She also had a wonderful vegetable garden. As a kid I would help her harvest and every now and then we’d see a bug. I’d start to smash it and she’d stop me. "Do you know the name of that bug?" she’d ask and if I didn’t, she would tell me to find it in her "bug book" first because it might be a "good bug."
I have since learned that most of those bugs in her garden were indeed good bugs and most of them were there because of the way she planted her garden, so different than other gardens in the area. She had rows but, in each row, she planted many different types of vegetables and flowers. Flowers and vegetables growing easily side by side as companion plants.
What Is Companion Planting?
Companion planting has a number of definitions. According to the ATTRA article Companion Planting & Botanical Pesticides: Concepts & Resources published April 2016
Companion planting can be described as establishing two or more plant species in close proximity for some cultural benefit…[it] is thought of as a small-scale gardening practice. However, here the term is applied in its broadest sense to include applications to commercial horticultural and agronomic crops.
There is a long history of companion planting but the mechanisms of how plant interactions work are still not completely understood. Botanists and agronomists study those plant interactions but seldom use the phrase “companion planting”. Perhaps because it has a folklore connotation?
Agronomists use terms like trap cropping, nitrogen fixation, weed suppression, biochemical pest suppression, and others – they are all aspects of companion planting.
Using legumes as cover crops in a field with a heavy feeding crop such as corn is companion planting. Planting flowers in a vegetable garden is also companion planting. Agronomists prefer to use the word “intercropping” to describe companion planting systems. So, if your agronomist talks about intercropping, he or she is talking about the age-old practice of companion planting.
Benefits Of Companion Planting For My Crops
Planting different crops side by side to maximize growth is one aspect of companion planting. My grandmother had learned from her mother, who had learned from her mother…
…that if you planted flowers in with the vegetables you got higher yields. You were also giving the good bugs a place to hang out while digesting their last meal of bad bugs. But it is more complicated than that. The benefits of good companions planting also include:
- Pest prevention
- Improved soil fertility
- Shade regulation
- Weed control
- Higher yields
And that’s just the tip of the iceberg. Many growers will tell you that proper companion planting will improve the taste of their crops.
Origins Of Companion Planting
The Native American "Three Sisters Garden" is the companion planting example most people have heard of. The Farmer’s Almanac describes this garden in a very interesting way
- As older sisters often do, the corn offers the beans needed support.
- The beans, the giving sister, pull nitrogen from the air and bring it to the soil for the benefit of all three.
- As the beans grow through the tangle of squash vines and wind their way up the cornstalks into the sunlight, they hold the sisters close together.
- The large leaves of the sprawling squash protect the threesome by creating living mulch that shades the soil, keeping it cool and moist and preventing weeds.
- The prickly squash leaves also keep away racoons and other pests, which don’t like to step on them.
- Together the three sisters provide both sustainable soil fertility as well as a healthy diet.
The Three Sisters garden concept can work in any modern garden.
But it will take some trial and error to find corn that can stand up to a climbing bean. I have grown Three Sisters gardens and found hybrid sweet corn stalks are too weak, multi-colored Indian popcorn stood up well to Scarlet Runner beans. Amaranth or sunflowers planting near crops gives added diversity which helps improve soil health.
How Do Plants Keep Pests Off My Crop
Some crops will repel pests of plants they are planted with by their odor, such as onions and many herbs. Other crops may work by attracting beneficial insects to the area. And still, other plants may just be tastier to the insect pest. For example, flea beetles can really damage a crop of broccoli, cabbage, peppers, or tomatoes but they prefer eggplant so planting an eggplant every so often acts as a trap plant. If you like eggplant this may be an issue because the flea beetles will probably kill the plant. But don’t lose all hope, there is a natural enemy for flea beetles, Microctonus vittatae, a braconid wasp, that can be ordered from an insectary. But be sure your issue really is flea beetles. A large part of pest control is knowing your bugs. I now have my own dog eared "bug book," Field Guide to Insects and Spiders of North America from the National Wildlife Federation.
Not all the pest problems are above ground. The damage of root-knot nematodes can cause slow-growing crops that are drought prone, fruit or flower poorly, and have short lives. The French marigold, Tagetes patula is effective against damaging nematodes. It produces a natural chemical that kills several types of nematodes. Marigolds are annual wherever it frosts; if you don’t like the look of the dead plant cut it off at the soil line, the roots MUST stay in the soil to be effective. If you have good soil and the winter isn’t too harsh the flowerheads you didn’t cut off may self-seed so your nematode problem could be a past problem.
Improving Soil Fertility
When you have a diversity of plants you will attract a diversity of soil organisms. Planting a diverse mixture of crops provides an environment that increases beneficial insect habitat, reduces the amount of damage from an insect or disease, and increases the biomass both above and below ground.
Intercropping can often act as living mulches (as in the squash in the Three Sisters garden). If you plant tall sun-loving plants so they capture the afternoon heat and sun and short shade-loving plants in their shadows they will all be happier. If the tall plants are tomatoes and the short plants are vining nasturtiums, for example, weed suppression and pest management will be greatly enhanced. Tomato hornworms are partial to nasturtiums so the flowering plant does double duty; weed suppression and trap plant.
At the end of the growing season cut off the biomass above ground. The microbes in the soil will need the decaying root matter as food over the winter. Over the years experts have told us to remove plant debris at the end of the season but, according to the Noble Research Institute
"As roots die, the entire organ becomes dinner for the microbial community along with other soil creatures like worms and insects. All these root-derived inputs are fundamental to creating and storing soil carbon and are a driving force for soil health, as increased soil carbon allows for better water infiltration and storage in pastures and fields."
Companion planting, or intercropping, increases the fertility of the soil. It also increases the number and type of beneficial insects.
Companion Planting Protects From Sun And Wind
In anybody’s garden or field there are crops that are prone to sunscald. Planting taller plants, such as sunflowers, corn, or indeterminate tomatoes in tall cages will take some of the heat off your peppers or salad greens. Plant them on the west side because the afternoons in August can get brutal. You don’t want to have nursed your plants all season just to lose them to the heat. This is also when you will be thankful you planted low-growing herbs like thyme or clover in your fields or garden. That vegetation keeps the moisture in the soil and reduces evaporation from winds.
Wind can be very detrimental in a monoculture field or a garden with low fertility. If your crop doesn’t have a substantial root system a strong summer wind and rain will lay your crop on its side. Taller plants are more susceptible to wind damage but if the soil is fertile their root systems will be stronger and better able to handle a hard rain. When you have a diversity of crops and you’ve left last year’s crop roots in the soil you have a diversity of decaying vegetative matter. That decaying vegetation underground is creating humus which will create healthier plants. The healthier the plants the more wind, extreme weather, and insects they can handle without loss of crop yield. Having those companion plant friends may make the difference between a loss and a good crop year.
Mulching will also help soil fertility and in turn, the health of your garden. Cutting above ground biomass and leaving it on the ground is one way to mulch. On a no-till farm that is achieved by growing a cover crop and then crimping it.
The Role Of Companion Plants In Weed Control
Making sure the soil is covered with vegetation is the primary way to control unwanted plants. This is where some crops that we wouldn’t generally think of as companion plants come to the forefront. We usually think of companion plants as another edible garden plant. But cover crops are also good companion plants. Seeding clover under your peppers and tomatoes keeps the ground covered AND fixes nitrogen in the soil AND attracts pollinators to increase your yield.
Some plants have allelochemicals that may negatively impact a crop, such as juglone from Black Walnut trees. Other plant allelochemicals are positive when used to suppress weed growth in a field or garden with transplants. Rye, cut or flattened, and left on the surface of the field or garden is considered one of the best crops for weed seed suppression. When you are transplanting your tomatoes or melons in rye cover create a hole, plant your seedling, water, and nature will help you out a great deal.
Higher Yields With Companion Planting
When your soil is fertile, you’ve suppressed the weed seeds, and you’ve planted companions to help with pest control everything is in place for higher yields. One more thing is needed, pollinators.
If you’ve been seeding some clovers and you have herbs in your garden or fields you are already attracting pollinators. But you can never have enough of them. One of the best ways to attract pollinators, as well as create habitat for good bugs is to plant flowers with your vegetables. In Lisa Ziegler’s book Vegetables Love Flowers, she writes when she started incorporating flowers in the family’s vegetable garden.
"…my garden filled up with pollinators and nature’s pest controls – especially welcome at a time when the number of beneficial insects in most gardens, especially bees, has been diminished by herbicide exposure and loss of habitat."
Her vegetable garden has a wide range of flowers she sells as beautiful bouquets. Those flowers bring in revenue AND are a welcome mat for pollinators and beneficial insects that also pollinate the vegetables. When you plant for pollinators you get higher yields in vegetable crops that are adjacent to flowers. Lisa writes it’s key to keep cutting the flowers or, just like vegetable plants, they will quit producing. As long as there are flowers with pollen and nectar there will be pollinators.
Companion planting is as narrow or as broad a topic as you need for your farm or garden. It can mean planting basil with a tomato plant in a pot, planting a trap plant every few plants in a garden, or it can mean sowing clover in your commercial tomato field. You will attract pollinators, beneficial insects, and retain moisture in the soil. The benefits of intercropping are easily scaled from a pot, to a garden, to a field.
Flowers in vases create connections with the living earth. We plant special beds for flowers but, if you look around, don’t you see flowers as companions in all environments? They are companions to trees, vegetables, and even those unwanted plants in your crop fields will flower. Why not help nature out by planting companion plants that will benefit your crops and create more fertile soil? It’s spring and time to go out and play in the garden. Or walk your fields. Cut a bouquet of diversity on your farm. Feel the synergy between you and those plants you have nurtured. The bonds between companions.